`non-global-value-max-name-size` is used by `Value` to cap the length of local value name. However, this flag is not considered by `LLParser`, which leads to unexpected `use of undefined value error`. The fix is to move the responsibility of capping the length to `ValueSymbolTable`.
The test is the one provided by [[ https://bugs.llvm.org/show_bug.cgi?id=45899 | Mikael in the bug report ]].
Reviewed By: mehdi_amini
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D102707
This is a follow-up of D102201. After some discussion, it is a better idea
to upgrade all invalid uses of alignment attributes on function return
values and parameters, not just limited to void function return types.
Reviewed By: jdoerfert
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D102726
The Linux kernel objtool diagnostic `call without frame pointer save/setup`
arise in multiple instrumentation passes (asan/tsan/gcov). With the mechanism
introduced in D100251, it's trivial to respect the command line
-m[no-]omit-leaf-frame-pointer/-f[no-]omit-frame-pointer, so let's do it.
Fix: https://github.com/ClangBuiltLinux/linux/issues/1236 (tsan)
Fix: https://github.com/ClangBuiltLinux/linux/issues/1238 (asan)
Also document the function attribute "frame-pointer" which is long overdue.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D101016
On ELF targets, if a function has uwtable or personality, or does not have
nounwind (`needsUnwindTableEntry`), it marks that `.eh_frame` is needed in the module.
Then, a function gets `.eh_frame` if `needsUnwindTableEntry` or `-g[123]` is specified.
(i.e. If -g[123], every function gets `.eh_frame`.
This behavior is strange but that is the status quo on GCC and Clang.)
Let's take asan as an example. Other sanitizers are similar.
`asan.module_[cd]tor` has no attribute. `needsUnwindTableEntry` returns true,
so every function gets `.eh_frame` if `-g[123]` is specified.
This is the root cause that
`-fno-exceptions -fno-asynchronous-unwind-tables -g` produces .debug_frame
while
`-fno-exceptions -fno-asynchronous-unwind-tables -g -fsanitize=address` produces .eh_frame.
This patch
* sets the nounwind attribute on sanitizer module ctor/dtor.
* let Clang emit a module flag metadata "uwtable" for -fasynchronous-unwind-tables. If "uwtable" is set, sanitizer module ctor/dtor additionally get the uwtable attribute.
The "uwtable" mechanism is generic: synthesized functions not cloned/specialized
from existing ones should consider `Function::createWithDefaultAttr` instead of
`Function::create` if they want to get some default attributes which
have more of module semantics.
Other candidates: "frame-pointer" (https://github.com/ClangBuiltLinux/linux/issues/955https://github.com/ClangBuiltLinux/linux/issues/1238), dso_local, etc.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D100251
When we pass a AArch64 Homogeneous Floating-Point
Aggregate (HFA) argument with increased alignment
requirements, for example
struct S {
__attribute__ ((__aligned__(16))) double v[4];
};
Clang uses `[4 x double]` for the parameter, which is passed
on the stack at alignment 8, whereas it should be at
alignment 16, following Rule C.4 in
AAPCS (https://github.com/ARM-software/abi-aa/blob/master/aapcs64/aapcs64.rst#642parameter-passing-rules)
Currently we don't have a way to express in LLVM IR the
alignment requirements of the function arguments. The align
attribute is applicable to pointers only, and only for some
special ways of passing arguments (e..g byval). When
implementing AAPCS32/AAPCS64, clang resorts to dubious hacks
of coercing to types, which naturally have the needed
alignment. We don't have enough types to cover all the
cases, though.
This patch introduces a new use of the stackalign attribute
to control stack slot alignment, when and if an argument is
passed in memory.
The attribute align is left as an optimizer hint - it still
applies to pointer types only and pertains to the content of
the pointer, whereas the alignment of the pointer itself is
determined by the stackalign attribute.
For byval arguments, the stackalign attribute assumes the
role, previously perfomed by align, falling back to align if
stackalign` is absent.
On the clang side, when passing arguments using the "direct"
style (cf. `ABIArgInfo::Kind`), now we can optionally
specify an alignment, which is emitted as the new
`stackalign` attribute.
Patch by Momchil Velikov and Lucas Prates.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D98794
This patch enhances hasAddressTaken() to ignore bitcasts as a
callee in callbase instruction. Such bitcast usage doesn't really take
the address in a useful meaningful way.
Reviewed By: rampitec
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D98884
I think byval/sret and the others are close to being able to rip out
the code to support the missing type case. A lot of this code is
shared with inalloca, so catch this up to the others so that can
happen.
In DeadArgumentElimination pass, if a function's argument is never used, corresponding caller's parameter can be changed to undef. If the param/arg has attribute noundef or other related attributes, LLVM LangRef(https://llvm.org/docs/LangRef.html#parameter-attributes) says its behavior is undefined. SimplifyCFG(D97244) takes advantage of this behavior and does bad transformation on valid code.
To avoid this undefined behavior when change caller's parameter to undef, this patch removes noundef attribute and other attributes imply noundef on param/arg.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D98899
This patch adds support for intrinsic overloading on unnamed types.
This fixes PR38117 and PR48340 and will also be needed for the Full Restrict Patches (D68484).
The main problem is that the intrinsic overloading name mangling is using 's_s' for unnamed types.
This can result in identical intrinsic mangled names for different function prototypes.
This patch changes this by adding a '.XXXXX' to the intrinsic mangled name when at least one of the types is based on an unnamed type, ensuring that we get a unique name.
Implementation details:
- The mapping is created on demand and kept in Module.
- It also checks for existing clashes and recycles potentially existing prototypes and declarations.
- Because of extra data in Module, Intrinsic::getName needs an extra Module* argument and, for speed, an optional FunctionType* argument.
- I still kept the original two-argument 'Intrinsic::getName' around which keeps the original behavior (providing the base name).
-- Main reason is that I did not want to change the LLVMIntrinsicGetName version, as I don't know how acceptable such a change is
-- The current situation already has a limitation. So that should not get worse with this patch.
- Intrinsic::getDeclaration and the verifier are now using the new version.
Other notes:
- As far as I see, this should not suffer from stability issues. The count is only added for prototypes depending on at least one anonymous struct
- The initial count starts from 0 for each intrinsic mangled name.
- In case of name clashes, existing prototypes are remembered and reused when that makes sense.
Reviewed By: fhahn
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D91250
Currently LLVM is relying on ValueTracking's `isKnownNonZero` to attach `nonnull`, which can return true when the value is poison.
To make the semantics of `nonnull` consistent with the behavior of `isKnownNonZero`, this makes the semantics of `nonnull` to accept poison, and return poison if the input pointer isn't null.
This makes many transformations like below legal:
```
%p = gep inbounds %x, 1 ; % p is non-null pointer or poison
call void @f(%p) ; instcombine converts this to call void @f(nonnull %p)
```
Instead, this semantics makes propagation of `nonnull` to caller illegal.
The reason is that, passing poison to `nonnull` does not immediately raise UB anymore, so such program is still well defined, if the callee does not use the argument.
Having `noundef` attribute there re-allows this.
```
define void @f(i8* %p) { ; functionattr cannot mark %p nonnull here anymore
call void @g(i8* nonnull %p) ; .. because @g never raises UB if it never uses %p.
ret void
}
```
Another attribute that needs to be updated is `align`. This patch updates the semantics of align to accept poison as well.
Reviewed By: jdoerfert
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D90529
The x86_amx is used for AMX intrisics. <256 x i32> is bitcast to x86_amx when
it is used by AMX intrinsics, and x86_amx is bitcast to <256 x i32> when it
is used by load/store instruction. So amx intrinsics only operate on type x86_amx.
It can help to separate amx intrinsics from llvm IR instructions (+-*/).
Thank Craig for the idea. This patch depend on https://reviews.llvm.org/D87981.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D91927
While I was adding a new intrinsic instruction (not overloaded), I accidentally used CreateUnaryIntrinsic to create the intrinsics, which turns out to be passing the type list to getName, and ended up naming the intrinsics function with type suffix, which leads to wierd bugs latter on. It took me a long time to debug.
It seems a good idea to add an assertion in getName so that it fails if types are passed but it's not a overloaded function.
Also, the overloade version of getName is less efficient because it creates an std::string. We should avoid calling it if we know that there are no types provided.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D92523
It's common for code that manipulates the stack via inline assembly or
that has to set up its own stack canary (such as the Linux kernel) would
like to avoid stack protectors in certain functions. In this case, we've
been bitten by numerous bugs where a callee with a stack protector is
inlined into an attribute((no_stack_protector)) caller, which
generally breaks the caller's assumptions about not having a stack
protector. LTO exacerbates the issue.
While developers can avoid this by putting all no_stack_protector
functions in one translation unit together and compiling those with
-fno-stack-protector, it's generally not very ergonomic or as
ergonomic as a function attribute, and still doesn't work for LTO. See also:
https://lore.kernel.org/linux-pm/20200915172658.1432732-1-rkir@google.com/https://lore.kernel.org/lkml/20200918201436.2932360-30-samitolvanen@google.com/T/#u
SSP attributes can be ordered by strength. Weakest to strongest, they
are: ssp, sspstrong, sspreq. Callees with differing SSP attributes may be
inlined into each other, and the strongest attribute will be applied to the
caller. (No change)
After this change:
* A callee with no SSP attributes will no longer be inlined into a
caller with SSP attributes.
* The reverse is also true: a callee with an SSP attribute will not be
inlined into a caller with no SSP attributes.
* The alwaysinline attribute overrides these rules.
Functions that get synthesized by the compiler may not get inlined as a
result if they are not created with the same stack protector function
attribute as their callers.
Alternative approach to https://reviews.llvm.org/D87956.
Fixes pr/47479.
Signed-off-by: Nick Desaulniers <ndesaulniers@google.com>
Reviewed By: rnk, MaskRay
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D91816
This patch changes the intrinsics cost model to assume that by default
target intrinsics are cheap. This didn't seem to be the case for all
intrinsics, and is potentially an MVE problem due to our scalarization
overheads. Cheap seems to be a good default in general though.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D90597
This patch adds support for assemble disassemble intrinsics
for MMA.
Reviewed By: bsaleil, #powerpc
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D88739
Key Locker provides a mechanism to encrypt and decrypt data with an AES key without having access
to the raw key value by converting AES keys into “handles”. These handles can be used to perform the
same encryption and decryption operations as the original AES keys, but they only work on the current
system and only until they are revoked. If software revokes Key Locker handles (e.g., on a reboot),
then any previous handles can no longer be used.
Reviewed By: craig.topper
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D88398
This patch prevents the `llvm.masked.gather` and `llvm.masked.scatter` intrinsics to be scalarized when invoked on scalable vectors.
The change in `Function.cpp` is needed to prevent the warning that is raised when `getNumElements` is used in place of `getElementCount` on `VectorType` instances. The tests guards for regressions on this change.
The tests makes sure that calls to `llvm.masked.[gather|scatter]` are still scalarized when:
# the intrinsics are operating on fixed size vectors, and
# the compiler is not targeting fixed length SVE code generation.
Reviewed By: efriedma, sdesmalen
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D86249
This patch changes ElementCount so that the Min and Scalable
members are now private and can only be accessed via the get
functions getKnownMinValue() and isScalable(). In addition I've
added some other member functions for more commonly used operations.
Hopefully this makes the class more useful and will reduce the
need for calling getKnownMinValue().
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D86065
For a long time, the InstCombine pass handled target specific
intrinsics. Having target specific code in general passes was noted as
an area for improvement for a long time.
D81728 moves most target specific code out of the InstCombine pass.
Applying the target specific combinations in an extra pass would
probably result in inferior optimizations compared to the current
fixed-point iteration, therefore the InstCombine pass resorts to newly
introduced functions in the TargetTransformInfo when it encounters
unknown intrinsics.
The patch should not have any effect on generated code (under the
assumption that code never uses intrinsics from a foreign target).
This introduces three new functions:
TargetTransformInfo::instCombineIntrinsic
TargetTransformInfo::simplifyDemandedUseBitsIntrinsic
TargetTransformInfo::simplifyDemandedVectorEltsIntrinsic
A few target specific parts are left in the InstCombine folder, where
it makes sense to share code. The largest left-over part in
InstCombineCalls.cpp is the code shared between arm and aarch64.
This allows to move about 3000 lines out from InstCombine to the targets.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D81728
This allows tracking the in-memory type of a pointer argument to a
function for ABI purposes. This is essentially a stripped down version
of byval to remove some of the stack-copy implications in its
definition.
This includes the base IR changes, and some tests for places where it
should be treated similarly to byval. Codegen support will be in a
future patch.
My original attempt at solving some of these problems was to repurpose
byval with a different address space from the stack. However, it is
technically permitted for the callee to introduce a write to the
argument, although nothing does this in reality. There is also talk of
removing and replacing the byval attribute, so a new attribute would
need to take its place anyway.
This is intended avoid some optimization issues with the current
handling of aggregate arguments, as well as fixes inflexibilty in how
frontends can specify the kernel ABI. The most honest representation
of the amdgpu_kernel convention is to expose all kernel arguments as
loads from constant memory. Today, these are raw, SSA Argument values
and codegen is responsible for turning these into loads.
Background:
There currently isn't a satisfactory way to represent how arguments
for the amdgpu_kernel calling convention are passed. In reality,
arguments are passed in a single, flat, constant memory buffer
implicitly passed to the function. It is also illegal to call this
function in the IR, and this is only ever invoked by a driver of some
kind.
It does not make sense to have a stack passed parameter in this
context as is implied by byval. It is never valid to write to the
kernel arguments, as this would corrupt the inputs seen by other
dispatches of the kernel. These argumets are also not in the same
address space as the stack, so a copy is needed to an alloca. From a
source C-like language, the kernel parameters are invisible.
Semantically, a copy is always required from the constant argument
memory to a mutable variable.
The current clang calling convention lowering emits raw values,
including aggregates into the function argument list, since using
byval would not make sense. This has some unfortunate consequences for
the optimizer. In the aggregate case, we end up with an aggregate
store to alloca, which both SROA and instcombine turn into a store of
each aggregate field. The optimizer never pieces this back together to
see that this is really just a copy from constant memory, so we end up
stuck with expensive stack usage.
This also means the backend dictates the alignment of arguments, and
arbitrarily picks the LLVM IR ABI type alignment. By allowing an
explicit alignment, frontends can make better decisions. For example,
there's real no advantage to an aligment higher than 4, so a frontend
could choose to compact the argument layout. Similarly, there is a
high penalty to using an alignment lower than 4, so a frontend could
opt into more padding for small arguments.
Another design consideration is when it is appropriate to expose the
fact that these arguments are all really passed in adjacent
memory. Currently we have a late IR optimization pass in codegen to
rewrite the kernel argument values into explicit loads to enable
vectorization. In most programs, unrelated argument loads can be
merged together. However, exposing this property directly from the
frontend has some disadvantages. We still need a way to track the
original argument sizes and alignments to report to the driver. I find
using some side-channel, metadata mechanism to track this
unappealing. If the kernel arguments were exposed as a single buffer
to begin with, alias analysis would be unaware that the padding bits
betewen arguments are meaningless. Another family of problems is there
are still some gaps in replacing all of the available parameter
attributes with metadata equivalents once lowered to loads.
The immediate plan is to start using this new attribute to handle all
aggregate argumets for kernels. Long term, it makes sense to migrate
all kernel arguments, including scalars, to be passed indirectly in
the same manner.
Additional context is in D79744.
When the byref attribute is added, there will need to be two similar
functions for the existing cases which have an associate value copy,
and byref which does not. Most, but not all of the existing uses will
use the existing version.
The associated size function added by D82679 also needs to
contextually differ, and will help eliminate a few places still
relying on pointee element types.
Summary:
Ignore callback uses when adding a callback function
in the CallGraph. Callback functions are typically
created when outlining, e.g. for OpenMP, so they have
internal scope and linkage. They should not be added
to the ExternalCallingNode since they are only callable
by the specified caller function at creation time.
A CGSCC pass, such as OpenMPOpt, may need to update
the CallGraph by adding a new outlined callback function.
Without ignoring callback uses, adding breaks CGSCC
pass restrictions and results to a broken CallGraph.
Reviewers: jdoerfert
Subscribers: hiraditya, sstefan1, llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D83370
This likely has broken test/Transforms/Attributor/IPConstantProp/ tests.
http://45.33.8.238/linux/22502/step_12.txt
This reverts commit 205dc0922d5f7305226f7457fcbcb4224c92530c.
Summary:
Ignore callback uses when adding a callback function
in the CallGraph. Callback functions are typically
created when outlining, e.g. for OpenMP, so they have
internal scope and linkage. They should not be added
to the ExternalCallingNode since they are only callable
by the specified caller function at creation time.
A CGSCC pass, such as OpenMPOpt, may need to update
the CallGraph by adding a new outlined callback function.
Without ignoring callback uses, adding breaks CGSCC
pass restrictions and results to a broken CallGraph.
Reviewers: jdoerfert
Subscribers: hiraditya, sstefan1, llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D83370
Since none of these users really care about the actual type, hide the
type under a new size-getting attribute to go along with
hasPassPointeeByValueAttr. This will work better for the future byref
attribute, which may end up only tracking the byte size and not the IR
type.
We currently have 3 parameter attributes that should carry the type
(technically inalloca does not yet). The APIs are somewhat awkward
since preallocated/inalloca piggyback on byval in some places, but in
others are treated as distinct attributes. Since these are all
mutually exclusive, we should probably just merge all the attribute
infrastructure treating these as totally distinct attributes.
In an earlier patch I removed the need for
IITDescriptor::ScalableVecArgument, which involved changing
DecodeIITType to pull out the last IIT_Info from the list. However,
it turns out this is unsafe and causes ubsan failures. I've tried to
fix this a different way by simply passing the last IIT_Info as an
additional argument to DecodeIITType.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D81057
I have refactored the code so that we no longer need the
ScalableVecArgument descriptor - the scalable property of vectors is
now encoded using the ElementCount class in IITDescriptor. This means
that when matching intrinsics we know precisely how to match the
arguments and return values.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D80107
See https://reviews.llvm.org/D74651 for the preallocated IR constructs
and LangRef changes.
In X86TargetLowering::LowerCall(), if a call is preallocated, record
each argument's offset from the stack pointer and the total stack
adjustment. Associate the call Value with an integer index. Store the
info in X86MachineFunctionInfo with the integer index as the key.
This adds two new target independent ISDOpcodes and two new target
dependent Opcodes corresponding to @llvm.call.preallocated.{setup,arg}.
The setup ISelDAG node takes in a chain and outputs a chain and a
SrcValue of the preallocated call Value. It is lowered to a target
dependent node with the SrcValue replaced with the integer index key by
looking in X86MachineFunctionInfo. In
X86TargetLowering::EmitInstrWithCustomInserter() this is lowered to an
%esp adjustment, the exact amount determined by looking in
X86MachineFunctionInfo with the integer index key.
The arg ISelDAG node takes in a chain, a SrcValue of the preallocated
call Value, and the arg index int constant. It produces a chain and the
pointer fo the arg. It is lowered to a target dependent node with the
SrcValue replaced with the integer index key by looking in
X86MachineFunctionInfo. In
X86TargetLowering::EmitInstrWithCustomInserter() this is lowered to a
lea of the stack pointer plus an offset determined by looking in
X86MachineFunctionInfo with the integer index key.
Force any function containing a preallocated call to use the frame
pointer.
Does not yet handle a setup without a call, or a conditional call.
Does not yet handle musttail. That requires a LangRef change first.
Tried to look at all references to inalloca and see if they apply to
preallocated. I've made preallocated versions of tests testing inalloca
whenever possible and when they make sense (e.g. not alloca related,
inalloca edge cases).
Aside from the tests added here, I checked that this codegen produces
correct code for something like
```
struct A {
A();
A(A&&);
~A();
};
void bar() {
foo(foo(foo(foo(foo(A(), 4), 5), 6), 7), 8);
}
```
by replacing the inalloca version of the .ll file with the appropriate
preallocated code. Running the executable produces the same results as
using the current inalloca implementation.
Reverted due to unexpectedly passing tests, added REQUIRES: asserts for reland.
Subscribers: hiraditya, llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D77689
See https://reviews.llvm.org/D74651 for the preallocated IR constructs
and LangRef changes.
In X86TargetLowering::LowerCall(), if a call is preallocated, record
each argument's offset from the stack pointer and the total stack
adjustment. Associate the call Value with an integer index. Store the
info in X86MachineFunctionInfo with the integer index as the key.
This adds two new target independent ISDOpcodes and two new target
dependent Opcodes corresponding to @llvm.call.preallocated.{setup,arg}.
The setup ISelDAG node takes in a chain and outputs a chain and a
SrcValue of the preallocated call Value. It is lowered to a target
dependent node with the SrcValue replaced with the integer index key by
looking in X86MachineFunctionInfo. In
X86TargetLowering::EmitInstrWithCustomInserter() this is lowered to an
%esp adjustment, the exact amount determined by looking in
X86MachineFunctionInfo with the integer index key.
The arg ISelDAG node takes in a chain, a SrcValue of the preallocated
call Value, and the arg index int constant. It produces a chain and the
pointer fo the arg. It is lowered to a target dependent node with the
SrcValue replaced with the integer index key by looking in
X86MachineFunctionInfo. In
X86TargetLowering::EmitInstrWithCustomInserter() this is lowered to a
lea of the stack pointer plus an offset determined by looking in
X86MachineFunctionInfo with the integer index key.
Force any function containing a preallocated call to use the frame
pointer.
Does not yet handle a setup without a call, or a conditional call.
Does not yet handle musttail. That requires a LangRef change first.
Tried to look at all references to inalloca and see if they apply to
preallocated. I've made preallocated versions of tests testing inalloca
whenever possible and when they make sense (e.g. not alloca related,
inalloca edge cases).
Aside from the tests added here, I checked that this codegen produces
correct code for something like
```
struct A {
A();
A(A&&);
~A();
};
void bar() {
foo(foo(foo(foo(foo(A(), 4), 5), 6), 7), 8);
}
```
by replacing the inalloca version of the .ll file with the appropriate
preallocated code. Running the executable produces the same results as
using the current inalloca implementation.
Subscribers: hiraditya, llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D77689
The "null-pointer-is-valid" attribute needs to be checked by many
pointer-related combines. To make the check more efficient, convert
it from a string into an enum attribute.
In the future, this attribute may be replaced with data layout
properties.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D78862
Summary:
The BFloat IR type is introduced to provide support for, initially, the BFloat16
datatype introduced with the Armv8.6 architecture (optional from Armv8.2
onwards). It has an 8-bit exponent and a 7-bit mantissa and behaves like an IEEE
754 floating point IR type.
This is part of a patch series upstreaming Armv8.6 features. Subsequent patches
will upstream intrinsics support and C-lang support for BFloat.
Reviewers: SjoerdMeijer, rjmccall, rsmith, liutianle, RKSimon, craig.topper, jfb, LukeGeeson, sdesmalen, deadalnix, ctetreau
Subscribers: hiraditya, llvm-commits, danielkiss, arphaman, kristof.beyls, dexonsmith
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D78190
I have changed the ScalableVecArgument case in matchIntrinsicType
to create a new FixedVectorType. This means that the next case we
hit (Vector) will not assert when calling getNumElements(), since
we know that it's always a FixedVectorType. This is a temporary
measure for now, and it will be fixed properly in another patch
that refactors this code.
The changes are covered by this existing test:
CodeGen/AArch64/sve-intrinsics-fp-converts.ll
In addition, I have added a new test to ensure that we correctly
reject SVE intrinsics when called with fixed length vector types.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D79416
